Petrillo`s Pizza in Madison

I love Petrillo's Pizza! Everyone is super nice and I have always felt welcomed. Being surrounded by so many pizza places by my school, this is by far the best. My personal favorite item that they have is their mozzarella sticks. Anytime I have the chance to eat their pizza, I am always so excited. Can't wait to go back!

Prompt Delivery, pleasant drivers from when I've ordered delivery, same for the bartenders and waitresses when I've gone there with friends or family, MOST IMPORTANTLY, GREAT FOOD!!

Dude, I ordered a za the other day; I have two words for you, fermented dough! BAM!!!!!

Great food, great service. My favorite restaurant in Shoreline

We loved the pizza here, one of the best in the area. We have a family tradition we call "Pizza Friday" and we like to try new places to find the perfect pie, this is for sure on the top.Had 2 and loved them both. Service is also something to mention, very attenttive and friendly.Will go Back.

I've been eating at Petrillo's for years and love their food. Delivery service is great and always on time, and their dining room has a wonderful atmosphere!

Really good food!! Atmosphere was great and everyone is so so nice! Can't wait to go back!

I have been Ordering the pizza from Petrillo's since they were over on the east side of town. Tasty thin crust pizza. Now with a full menu and Bar. Daily food specials are always great. Several beers on tap. Nice local pub.

Pizza was absolutely delicious and some of the best I've ever had! Staff was super friendly and I will definitely be ordering from here again!

Best pizza in the area and amazing service! Pertrillo's is always my go to pizza place

Very, very good food. Great friendly customer service. I regularly order from here. I choose Petrillos over any other pizza place nearby. Keep up the great service!! Thank you for the kindness and amazing food

Great place food and service!!

Pizza was delicious!!! The service was great as well. Such a cute pizzeria to be in and so many different pizza choices! Highly recommend!!

The meat pizza and cheese pizza are amazing here!

It's not good at all. Don't waste your time. I gave them 3 chances. Each time was worst than the last.

If you want a truly wonderful experience from start to finish Petrillo's is THE only place to get pizza in Madison. Delicious pizza, exquisite service ....I ordered a pizza to be delivered on a day that was less than spectacular and Victor, Clem and Eddy completely turned my day around with their kindness and YUMMY pizza! Thank you guys! Can't wait for my next pizza! :)

I highly recommend dining in or ording from Petrillos. My family orders from here and never had any problems or complaints.

Great food & nice owner and staff.

This place has a nice ambience & the food here is really great. the owner even greeted us. would recommend this place to a friend or family

great food and a great family atmosphere!! I definitely plan on going back!

Good food, from excellent pizza to perfectly cooked steaks, Petrillo's is our go-to spot. Comfortable setting, fair prices and great service will bring you back again and again.

Love pizza clams casino

Got two orders to go. Wife enjoyed her Petrillo Salad with grilled chicken, mixed greens, cucumbers, roasted peppers, carrot strips, grape tomatoes, mandarin oranges, dried cranberries, fresh mozzarella cheese, croutons & gorgonzola cheese. And my son enjoyed his Chicken Parmesan grinder. One star removed because all the people in the restaurant including the bartender and 9 customers had no masks on. The person who gave me the order had a mask on though. We are living in a pandemic... let’s be smarter folks!

I didnt actually end up getting food from there so i dont know how good it is. all i know is that i called and politely asked if its possible for me to order below the delivery minimum if i got an extra fee. The man on the phone rudely responded "no you cant, we have that rule for a reason". If he politely said no than I would have ordered a couple of things to get the minimum but he was rude enough to make me not be a customer.

Excellent pizza..thin crispy crust. We love the shrimp quesadillas and burgers. Delicious salads and wraps! Our go to for wings and skins. We’ve been customers for years. Extremely accommodating! Really great, friendly owners and staff.

Great pastrami sandwich!

The food and service i had at Petrillo's was one of a kind! The food tasted like that home-made taste I'm always looking for and the service made me also feel so welcome like I was at home. Definitely will be returning to them as often as possible.

Petrillo's is a nice little neighborhood pub. Great for an inexpensive night with the fam on the dining side... Or a nice grown up night with the hubby on the bar side. Great food, good prices. I would highly recommend checking it out.

Great food friendly staff

GREAT food with great people!!

They took forever deliver and the pizza is no longer hot

The owner went way out of his way for the Madison family's during this time 🤗

Great pizza! Delivery is fast and affordable. Pizza is great and always warm when delivered. Staff is great and very welcoming right when you walk in! I highly recommend dining or ordering from there!

Love this place! Great food Great service, and an excellent bar area like an old town pub with friendly faces and great conversations. Game days are also fantastik!!

Fast delivery!

We get their pizza delivered to our work every Monday and we all love it so much we look forward to Mondays.

Horrible fish n chips. The whole meal was soggy and tiny portioned

Arrived almost 2 hours before closing but the lady serving us made it her mission to let us know how much of an inconvenience we were to her the whole time we were there. We ordered food within 5 minutes and it only took us 15 minutes to eat our dinner, but that was still too inconsiderate of us as we were impeding on her time.

Great food,great staff and cold beer

Happy Hour half price appetizers, great pizza, and excellent drinks. All with a friendly neighborhood atmosphere.Rudy is an exceptional bar tender.The rest of the staff are also fast, very friendly, very helpful, and excellent people.

Great place! GoofFood,desserts and fun atmosphere :)

I find it sad how unprofessional all of the staff (including the defensive owner) is whenever a mistake is pointed out to them. The customer is supposed to feel welcomed, not like an inconvenience to the staff. 1 star/will not return.

I'm on crutches and just took my pup to an emergency vet a few doors down from Petrillos Pizza. They have a lovely little bench outside their door and I sat down to rest. They came out and rather than tell me I had to move or purchase something, they brought water for my dog and wanted to know if I needed any help. How nice is that in today's world? Btw they have foxon park diet Birch beer which is my favorite! I'll be sure to eat here next time I'm around!!!!

I've been in Madison for years now and Petrillos is the only place I've ordered my pizza from consistently. The delivery time is always quick (usually on the lower end of their estimate) and the pizza is always solid.

Friendly wait staff, fast food service, and good food.

This place cannot get a delivery order right if it was tattooed on their forehead. That said food is ok but cheap wich is good. The people who work there are generally pleseant if ever really helpfull.

Such an amazing place with great food and even greater people! Definitely somewhere I will continue to go back to!

Petrillo's Pizza is so good, one of the best in the area! The food is always delicious and the staff is friendly and welcoming!! Always a good choice!

Petrillo's is a great family pizza place and restaurant! Not only is the food reasonably priced, but it is delicious! They have great specials and over 10 different beers on tap. I love the family vibe, will be returning again!

Very,very delicious pizza 🍕 😋 👌 😋